Occasionally, live-action Disney remakes are not welcomed by fans and critics. More than once, they stirred debate around the directors’ creative choices. Adapting an animated movie is not easy, especially when many of these Disney masterpieces rely on their characters’ unlikely and absurd antics as well as the otherworldly portrayal of magic to both entertain and enchant the audience. And as many special effects as one might use, it’s not the same.
Nevertheless, through other creative skills, some moments in these live-action Disney adaptations successfully captured the charmed core of the originals, managing to rival them. Whether through powerful performances, innovative visuals, or reinvented storytelling, these scenes prove that live action can occasionally bring something new to beloved classics, bringing the viewer back to their first, magical encounter with the story while offering a different perspective.
10 Cinderella Meets The Fairy Godmother
Cinderella (2015)
Considering how treasured the original movie is, Cinderella was a risky adaptation: the live-action Disney remake had to capture the character’s quiet bravery. However, besides Lily James’ performance, there is one character who truly shines in one of the story’s best moments: the Fairy Godmother. In the 1950 classic, the encounter between Cinderella and her magical godmother offers hope after seeing the poor young woman suffer a seemingly endless struggle. It is a sweet moment that concludes with Cinderella’s transformation into the princess she was always meant to be.
The remake’s scene maintains its deeply emotional quality while also adding a touch of humor and mischievous charm, accentuated by the radiant performance of Helena Bonham Carter. One cannot expect anything short of iconic when this actress is involved. The new Fairy Godmother is every bit as forgetful and endearing as her 1950 counterpart, but with a quirky appeal that makes her feel more dynamic. Paired with Cinderella’s gentle nature, the interaction between the two is not only heartwarming but comical, rivaling the original.
9 The “Circle Of Life” Sequence
The Lion King (2019)
The opening sequence of the 1994 animated classic The Lion King is one of the most iconic moments in cinematic history. Set to the poignant notes of “The Circle of Life”, the scene celebrates the pristine beauty of the African Savannah, where its animal populations honor the birth of their future Lion King, Simba. The stunning animation, paired with the majestic score and heartfelt lyrics, creates a sense of grandeur, acknowledging the themes of life and destiny the plot explores. It was an important legacy to live up to.
Related
Every Upcoming Animated Disney Movie
From the whimsical Strange World to the Toy Story prequel Lightyear, Disney and Pixar have some exciting animated movies coming in the near future.
Although the movie received mixed opinions from critics (despite its commercial success), the 2019 live-action remake provided the opportunity to experience one of the most famous scenes in cinematic history on a more authentic and immersive level through its photorealistically animated design. The scene is a flawless remaking of the original, allowing viewers to relive their cherished Disney memories. It almost seems like a musical version of a NatGeo documentary. Fortunately, there will be other occasions to enjoy new live-action remake moments rivaling The Lion King‘s.
8 Gaston’s & LeFou’s Song
Beauty And The Beast (2017)
If in the original Beauty and the Beast, Belle and the Beast stole the show, the 2017 remake majorly benefited from the performances of Luke Evans as Gaston and Josh Gad as LeFou. Their rendition of the song dedicated to the former is an electrifying moment that makes a spectacle of the grotesque foolishness of the movie’s villain with a comedic prowess that the original classic lacked. Evans’ over-the-top portrayal of Gaston amplifies his arrogance, ridiculing him, while Gad’s LeFou brings an unexpected depth to the role, making the duo compelling to watch.
As much as the famous scene from the animated film allowed for wild stunts and improbable physical displays, the presence of the two actors added a certain charm. Evans’ self-deprecating musical performance, despite his character’s confidence, makes Gaston, if not likable, at least mesmerizing. Gad’s almost serenade to his friend turns LeFou into an endearing, almost romantic pseudo-villain. The lively choreography and vibrant visuals further accentuated the scene. The duo made this animated Disney movie remake magical.
7 Shere Khan’s Entrance
The Jungle Book (2016)
The Jungle Book live-action remake did not disappoint: The movie was an excellent adaptation of the original story, capturing the volatility of the jungle and delivering nuanced performances. Many moments in the film stand out and rival the scenes in the original, but one in particular, because of its emotional intensity, emerges” Shere Khan’s first appearance. In the 1967 movie, the tiger is introduced as the top of the hierarchy in the jungle, with a quiet yet commanding demeanor.
The 2016 introduction, however, is even more chilling. With an insane CGI production, the experience feels almost too real. The tense anticipation before the tiger’s arrival, from the uneasy music to the quiet apprehension on the other animals’ faces, only amplifies the element of fear. This version of Shere Khan feels simultaneously more nuanced and alarming. The cold, collected gaze, the commanding voice of Idris Elba, and the threatening attitude all contribute to the scene’s anxiety-ridden atmosphere while capturing the nuances of Disney’s tragic villain.
6 The Genie’s Prince Ali Introduction
Aladdin (2019)
The musical introduction of “Prince Ali” in Aladdin, performed by the Genie, is one of the most extravagant and over-the-top moments in Disney history. The 2019 live-action remake brings that same spectacle to life in a revised yet equally captivating way. Robin Williams, as the original Genie, will always be incomparable, but Will Smith, with this high-spirited performance, came very close.
The live-action remake, unfortunately, could not use the same absurd, magical effects and count on a larger-than-life presence for Genie, but it nonetheless showcases a vibrant excitement that characterizes the original scene. Smith is, after all, a splendid performer who allowed his character to shine without the need for enchantments or spells but through his raw charisma. The parade of dancers, acrobats, and grand visuals still deliver a sense of wonder, allowing this live-action Disney remake moment to honor a beloved character.
5 Gaston & The Beast Fight
Beauty And The Beast (2017)
The fight between Gaston and the Beast is a crucial moment in the story, at the climax of the movie. In the 1991 version, the scene is a messy, brutal battle in the rain that sees Gaston at his most arrogant and cruel, while his enemy appears as an angry but mainly pitiful creature, tired of being treated like a beast. The scene comes across as a particularly uneasy and emotional watch.
Related
16 Live-Action Disney Remakes Broken Down By Box Office
Disney’s live action remakes of their classic animated movies have been a big hit. Here’s how their box office earnings rank and compare.
The 2017 live-action remake does not shy away from the intensity of the original scene. Perhaps because of the brilliant performance of Evans as Gaston, who, despite his cruelty, appears more as a multi-faceted character, the scene hits differently. It is the pinnacle of Gaston’s moral descent, a hurt, defeated man whose pride has been scarred and who is unwilling to let go. If the dance at the tavern captures the villain’s arrogance comically, this brutal life-action moment portrays his realistically terrifying nature.
4 Cruella’s Iconic Entrance
101 Dalmatians (1996)
Cruella’s iconic entrance is one of the most glamorous scenes in Disney history, and the 1996 live-action remake only further cements her legendary status. In the original animated movie, her introduction perfectly captures the essence of the character: a striking, haughty figure draped in fur, with a villainous glint in her eyes and an overly dramatic talk. As an antagonist, she couldn’t have been more instantly iconic. Meanwhile, The live-action Disney remake captured Cruella’s wickedness to perfection.
The arrival in the 1996 movie does not lose the magic. Cruella arrives at her work instead of her friend Anita’s house, with terrifying anticipation for both the characters, scared of her cruelty, and the audience, at this point aware of her malicious intentions. The introduction is a slow-burn, tension-filled moment, where the build-up only amplifies her chilling persona. Glenn Close’s dramatic opening with the notorious “Anita, Darling” further cements the scene as an excellent homage to the original.
3 Dumbo’s Flight
Dumbo (2019)
Despite the negative reception, Tim Burton’s Dumbo managed to embody the gloomy nature of the original story. The Disney cartoon is not a happy tale, even if it ends on a positive note. However, it is still mostly a children’s movie, so they could not make it too brutal. Through his traditional eerie visuals and ability to illustrate shadier themes, Burton made Dumbo’s first flight a poignant scene that is less fairytale-like than its counterpart.
The moment takes place at one of the circus exhibitions; the scene is horrifying. Dumbo is a trapped baby elephant, lonely and scared, with terribly uncanny makeup that further emphasizes the ridiculous spectacle that the circus wants to make of him. Surrounded by fire in front of a public mostly disinterested in his well-being, the elephant is at a loss. The moment is heartbreaking. Until encouraged by the kindness of one of the few people who show concern for him, Dumbo makes a last attempt and flies, hinting at some glimmers of hope amid the pitiful spectacle.
2 The Mad Tea Party
Alice In Wonderland (2010)
Alice in Wonderland is a timeless and absurd story where the line between chaos and normality blurs over a journey that feels like a dream but no one truly knows if it is. No one could better direct this movie than Tim Burton. With his whimsical and dark sensibilities, Burton was the perfect choice to bring the ever-bizarre world of Wonderland to life. One of the reasons that Alice in Wonderland is still Burton’s biggest box office success is that his quirky surrealism matches the story. This was indeed proven by the tea party scene.
In this fantastical landscape, the Mad Hatter, the March Hare, and the Dormouse sit together to celebrate their unbirthdays and discuss whether Mia Wasikowska is the real Alice. While the original animated scene relies on the fantasy element, the live-action delves into themes of madness and illusion in a different light, infusing the moments and the characters in it with a dramatic, eerie energy. Johnny Depp’s demeanor captures the simultaneously funny and tragic eccentricity of the Mad Hatter, making the tea party feel like a fragile dreamscape that could soon transform into a nightmare.
1 The Red Queen’s “Off with Their Heads!”
Alice In Wonderland (2010)
The Red Queen’s “Off with Their Heads!” is among the most iconic lines in the history of Disney, and, once again, Burton did not shy away from taking the legendary and eccentric role to the extreme. Helena Bonham Carter, as usual, definitely contributed to making the character extraordinary.
In the cartoon, the Red Queen is a grotesque and cruel antagonist who easily loses her patience and enjoys having her enemies — or anyone who slightly annoys her — beheaded. As scary as the character is, there is not much nuance. In the Burton adaptation, the queen is portrayed with a subtle vulnerability and almost child-like pettiness that makes her not only terrifying but compelling. Her shrill “off with their heads” would almost sound like a petulant whine if it wasn’t for everyone’s acknowledgment of her terrible regime.
